To correct imbalances in training data, don’t oversample: Cluster

In experiments involving sound recognition, technique reduces error rate by 15% to 30%.

Most modern machine learning systems are classifiers. They take input data and sort it into categories: pictures of particular animals, vocalizations of particular words, words acting as particular parts of speech, and the like.

Ideally, when a system is being trained to perform multiple classifications — say, pictures of cats, dogs, and horses — it will see roughly the same number of training examples from each category. Otherwise, it will probably end up biased toward the category that it sees most frequently.

Sometimes, though, imbalances in training data are unavoidable, and somehow, the training process has to correct for them. This spring, at the International Conference on Acoustics, Speech, and Signal Processing, my colleagues and I will present a new technique for correcting such imbalances.

In experiments, we applied our technique to the problem of recognizing particular sounds, such as glass breaking or babies crying. We found that, for a type of neural network commonly used in audio detection, our technique reduced error rates by 15% to 30% over the standard technique for correcting data imbalances.

To get a sense of the problem of data imbalance, suppose that a classifier were trained on examples of three classes, and one of the classes had 20 times as much training data as the other two. By simply assigning every input to the overrepresented class, the classifier could achieve 90% accuracy on the training data; it would have little incentive to resolve borderline cases in favor of either of the other two classes.

The standard way to address data imbalances is simply to overweight the examples in the underrepresented classes: if a particular class has one-fifth as much training data as another, each of its examples should count five times as much.

A more sophisticated approach is to train a neural network to produce “embeddings” that capture differences between data in different classes. An embedding is a representation of a data item as a point in a fixed-dimensional space (a vector). A neural network can be trained to produce embeddings that maximize the distances between points in different classes. The embedding vectors, not the data themselves, then serve as inputs to a classifier.

Model depicting the stages in the training of an embedding network
Stages in the training of an embedding network. Initially, the embedding is random, with points representing data from three different classes jumbled together. After two passes through the training data, the embedding produces greater separation between data points (center left). After five passes through the data, the embedding reliably groups data of the same class together (center right and far right).

Data imbalance is a problem when learning embeddings, too, so during training, if any data class is larger than any others, it’s split into clusters that are approximately the size of the smallest class. (In the figure above, for instance, the dots on the red end of the color spectrum are all from the same class. As it was four times the size of the other two classes, it was split into four clusters.)

Historically, the problem with this approach has been that, during training, every time the neural network embeds a new data item, it has to measure the distance between that item and every other item it’s seen. For large data sets, this is impractically time consuming.

To solve this problem, our algorithm instead keeps a running measurement of the centroid of each data cluster in the embedding space. The centroid is the point that minimizes the average distance of all the points of the cluster (like a center of gravity). With each new embedding, our algorithm measures its distance from the centroids of the clusters, a much more efficient computation than exhaustively measuring pairwise distances.

Once the embedding network is trained, we use its outputs as training data for a new classifier, which, unlike the embedding network, applies labels to input data. We found that our system works best if we allow the process of training the classifier to adjust the internal settings of the embedding network, too.

We tested our system on four types of sounds from an industry-standard data set: dogs’ barks, babies’ cries, gunshots, and background sounds. We also experimented with two different network architectures for doing the embeddings: a small, efficient long short-term memory (LSTM) network and a larger, slower, but more accurate convolutional neural net (CNN). As a baseline, we used the same architectures but adjusted for data imbalances by overweighting underrepresented samples, rather than maximizing distances in the embedding space.

Across the board, our embeddings improved the performance of the LSTM model, reducing the error rate by 15% to 30% on particular sounds and by 22% overall. For many applications, smaller networks will be preferable because of their greater efficiency.

With the CNN model, the results were more varied. When the ratio of the sizes of the data classes was 6:1:2:16 (dog : baby : gunshot : background), the baseline CNN model slightly outperformed our system on the most underrepresented class (baby’s cries), with a relative error reduction of 6%. But our system’s advantage on the other two classes was great enough that it still performed better overall.

When the ratio of negative to positive data was larger, however (2:2:1:26), our system outperformed the CNN model across the board, with an average relative error reduction of 19%. This suggests that the greater the data imbalance, the greater the advantage our system enjoys.

Acknowledgments: Vipul Arora, Chao Wang

Related content

US, WA, Seattle
MULTIPLE POSITIONS AVAILABLE Employer: AMAZON.COM SERVICES LLC Offered Position: Research Scientist II Job Location: Seattle, Washington Job Number: AMZ10564041 Position Responsibilities: Interact with various software and business groups to develop an understanding of their business requirements and operational processes. Utilize acquired knowledge and business judgment to build decision-supporting and operational tools to improve the bottom line. Build quantitative mathematical models to represent a wide range of supply chain, transportation and logistics systems. Implement these models and tools through the use of modeling languages and engineering code in software languages such as Java, C++, C# or C. Gather required data for analysis and mathematical model building by writing ad-hoc scripts and database queries. Perform quantitative, economic, and numerical performance analyses of these systems under uncertainty using statistical and optimization tools. Create computer simulations to support operational decision-making. Identify areas with potential for improvement and work with internal teams to generate requirements to realize improvements. Design optimal or near optimal solution methodologies to be used by in-house decision support tools and software. Create software prototypes to verify and validate the devised solutions methodologies. Integrate prototypes into production systems using standard software development tools and methodologies. 40 hours / week, 8:00am-5:00pm, Salary Range: $136,000/year to $184,000/year Amazon is a total compensation company. Dependent on the position offered, equity, sign-on payments, and other forms of compensation may be provided as part of a total compensation package, in addition to a full range of medical, financial, and/or other benefits. For more information, visit: https://www.aboutamazon.com/workplace/employee-benefits. Amazon.com is an Equal Opportunity-Affirmative Action Employer – Minority / Female / Disability / Veteran / Gender Identity / Sexual Orientation.#0000
US, NY, New York
MULTIPLE POSITIONS AVAILABLE Employer: AMAZON.COM SERVICES LLC Offered Position: Applied Scientist II Job Location: New York, New York Job Number: AMZ10564066 Position Responsibilities: Participate in the design, development, evaluation, deployment and updating of data-driven models and analytical solutions for machine learning (ML) and/or natural language (NL) applications. Develop and/or apply statistical modeling techniques (e.g. Bayesian models and deep neural networks), optimization methods, and other ML techniques to different applications in business and engineering. Routinely build and deploy ML models on available data. Research and implement novel ML and statistical approaches to add value to the business. Mentor junior engineers and scientists. 40 hours / week, 8:00am-5:00pm, Salary Range: $172,400/year to $223,400/year. Amazon is a total compensation company. Dependent on the position offered, equity, sign-on payments, and other forms of compensation may be provided as part of a total compensation package, in addition to a full range of medical, financial, and/or other benefits. For more information, visit: https://www.aboutamazon.com/workplace/employee-benefits. Amazon.com is an Equal Opportunity-Affirmative Action Employer – Minority / Female / Disability / Veteran / Gender Identity / Sexual Orientation.#0000
US, TX, Austin
MULTIPLE POSITIONS AVAILABLE Employer: AMAZON.COM SERVICES LLC Offered Position: Data Scientist III Job Location: Austin, Texas Job Number: AMZ10593703 Position Responsibilities: Own the data science elements of various products to help with data-based decision making, product performance optimization, and product performance tracking. Work directly with product managers to help drive the design of the product. Work with Technical Product Managers to help drive the build planning. Translate business problems and products into data requirements and metrics. Initiate the design, development, and implementation of scientific analysis projects or deliverables. Own the analysis, modelling, system design, and development of data science solutions for products. Write documents and make presentations that explain model/analysis results to the business. Bridge the degree of uncertainty in both problem definition and data scientific solution approaches. Build consensus on data, metrics, and analysis to drive business and system strategy. Position Requirements: Master's degree or foreign equivalent degree in Statistics, Applied Mathematics, Economics, Engineering, Computer Science or a related field and two years of experience in the job offered or a related occupation. Employer will accept a Bachelor's degree or foreign equivalent degree in Statistics, Applied Mathematics, Economics, Engineering, Computer Science, or a related field and five years of progressive post-baccalaureate experience in the job offered or a related occupation as equivalent to the Master's degree and two years of experience. Must have one year of experience in the following skills: (1) building statistical models and machine learning models using large datasets from multiple resources; (2) building complex data analyses by leveraging scripting languages including Python, Java, or related scripting language; and (3) communicating with users, technical teams, and management to collect requirements, evaluate alternatives, and develop processes and tools to support the organization. Amazon.com is an Equal Opportunity-Affirmative Action Employer – Minority / Female / Disability / Veteran / Gender Identity / Sexual Orientation. 40 hours / week, 8:00am-5:00pm, Salary Range $159,200/year to $215,300/year. Amazon is a total compensation company. Dependent on the position offered, equity, sign-on payments, and other forms of compensation may be provided as part of a total compensation package, in addition to a full range of medical, financial, and/or other benefits. For more information, visit: https://www.aboutamazon.com/workplace/employee-benefits. #0000
US, WA, Redmond
Amazon Leo is building a low Earth orbit satellite broadband network to deliver fast, affordable connectivity to customers around the world, including those underserved by traditional infrastructure. Operating a live constellation and its ground network at scale means service disruptions are an inevitable reality, and how quickly we detect them, understand them, and prevent them from recurring defines the trust we earn as a connectivity provider. We are seeking a talented Senior Data Scientist to build the next generation of observability and availability science for the Leo network. Leo already detects outages, notifies affected customers, and restores service. The frontier is prediction and prevention: reasoning over complex network and ground-segment telemetry to autonomously detect anomalies before they reach customers, attribute root cause automatically across a sprawling event surface, and rationalize a large, still-maturing metric set so responders trust what the system tells them. In this role you will work backwards from the needs of customers and operations teams. You will own the scientific direction end to end, partnering closely with network engineers, the Network Operations Center, and the Incident Management team, and the Software and Networking orginization to translate a long-term science vision into concrete research and delivery roadmaps. Export Control Requirement: Due to applicable export control laws and regulations, candidates must be a U.S. citizen or national, U.S. permanent resident (i.e., current Green Card holder), or lawfully admitted into the U.S. as a refugee or granted asylum. Key job responsibilities * Own the observability and availability science end to end, from long-term vision to research roadmap to production delivery, working backwards from the needs of customers, the NOC, and network engineering. * Develop time-series and graph-based models with dynamic baselining that detect network and ground-segment anomalies before they cross the High Severity threshold, enabling proactive investigation rather than reactive response. * Reason over complex, multi-system telemetry to attribute cause automatically during live HSEs and LSEs, so Call Leaders and engineers spend time mitigating, not hunting. * Provide the science behind the network's bucketed availability decomposition (geometric and satellite coverage, ground and network segments, customer terminals, payload, and planning), attributing every movement to a true cause rather than noise, so leadership steers on signal and engineering effort lands where it actually moves availability and throughput. * Deliver the models, analyses, and metrics that feed the daily system readiness and validation review consumed by senior leadership and product and engineering, turning availability and throughput data into a defensible, evidence-based read on progress against GA entry criteria. * Own the recurring, fleet-wide "hot topic" investigations that span ASIC, firmware, payload, network, and planning, separating correlated symptoms from true root cause across thousands of nodes, quantifying how much availability or throughput each is costing, and answering whether it is a launch-blocking risk and whether it is improving. * Deliver alert correlation and deduplication, false-positive reduction, and metric-quality scoring so responders trust what the system tells them, directly supporting a large, still-maturing KPI set. * Tie your science to the unit the org actually measures: reduce detection and attribution time, raise availability against the network's bar, and increase the share of events prevented before customer impact. * Partner day to day with the Network Operations Center, Network Engineering, and the Incident Management (Call Leader) program; sit on live HSE/LSE bridges as the science partner and turn event learnings into model improvements. * Feed COEs and RCAs back into detection and attribution so recurring signatures are caught earlier, and help design and score gamedays that stress-test both the network and your models against real, closed events. * Build and deploy production pipelines on AWS (e.g., SageMaker, Bedrock, Glue) with model validation, monitoring, drift detection, and explainability, because operations teams must be able to trust and act on model output under pressure. * Set data-science standards, mentor scientists, and drive best practices across the Leo networking organization as the science function scales. * Produce explainable output and written narratives that let responders and leaders three or more levels up act on your models during and between events. A day in the life You might start by reviewing overnight anomaly detections and availability movements, join an HSE bridge as the science partner by midday, and spend the afternoon refining root-cause attribution models or presenting availability findings at the readiness review. About the team Amazon Leo Networking Software builds and operates the software behind Leo's satellite and ground network. Our science function partners with the NOC, Network Engineering and Incident Management to make the network more available and resilient, moving from reacting to outages to predicting and preventing them. As a Data Scientist III, you'll help shape that function as it grows.
US, CA, Santa Clara
Amazon Customer Service (CS) org’s mission is to make customer service interactions so good they become the primary reason customers choose Amazon. Customer Experience Products (CXP) supports this vision by building customer-facing solutions customers prefer because they work - reducing effort, shortening time to resolution, and building trust with every interaction. Our science team evaluates AI and Large Language Models (LLM)-driven solutions for both consumer-facing and CS associates-facing AI applications. We evaluate multi-modal, multi-turn, goal-oriented dialog systems (e.g. chatbot, voicebot) that can resolve customer issues and provide informational answers grounded by Amazon policy and help articles, at Amazon scale across multiple languages, intents and locales. These fine-tuned LLM solutions are designed to adapt to changing company policies and automate solutions to customer problems with conversational intelligence. Additionally, we're exploring with the partner associate-facing org on defining quality of LLM capabilities to improve the productivity of associates. Key job responsibilities - Lead development of Customer Service specific multi modal foundational models that improve chat and voice experiences. - Establish and evaluate rigorous testing and validation protocols for AI-driven systems. - Lead ongoing quality improvements for launched AI solutions - Collaborate closely with Product Managers, UX Designers, Applied Scientists, and Software Development Engineers. - Practice thought leadership and contribute to the overall science vision and strategic direction for AI-driven customer experience transformation initiatives. - Stay at the forefront of AI and machine learning technologies.
US, NY, New York
MULTIPLE POSITIONS AVAILABLE Employer: AMAZON.COM SERVICES LLC Offered Position: Data Scientist III Job Location: New York, New York Job Number: AMZ10444216 Position Responsibilities: Own the data science elements of various products to help with data-based decision making, product performance optimization, and product performance tracking. Work directly with product managers to help drive the design of the product. Work with Technical Product Managers to help drive the build planning. Translate business problems and products into data requirements and metrics. Initiate the design, development, and implementation of scientific analysis projects or deliverables. Own the analysis, modelling, system design, and development of data science solutions for products. Write documents and make presentations that explain model/analysis results to the business. Bridge the degree of uncertainty in both problem definition and data scientific solution approaches. Build consensus on data, metrics, and analysis to drive business and system strategy. Position Requirements: Master's degree or foreign equivalent degree in Statistics, Applied Mathematics, Economics, Engineering, Computer Science or a related field and two years of experience in the job offered or a related occupation. Employer will accept a Bachelor's degree or foreign equivalent degree in Statistics, Applied Mathematics, Economics, Engineering, Computer Science, or a related field and five years of progressive post-baccalaureate experience in the job offered or a related occupation as equivalent to the Master's degree and two years of experience. Must have one year of experience in the following skills: (1) building statistical models and machine learning models using large datasets from multiple resources; (2) building complex data analyses by leveraging scripting languages including Python, Java, or related scripting language; and (3) communicating with users, technical teams, and management to collect requirements, evaluate alternatives, and develop processes and tools to support the organization. Amazon.com is an Equal Opportunity-Affirmative Action Employer – Minority / Female / Disability / Veteran / Gender Identity / Sexual Orientation. 40 hours / week, 8:00am-5:00pm, Salary Range $175,100/year to $236,900/year. Amazon is a total compensation company. Dependent on the position offered, equity, sign-on payments, and other forms of compensation may be provided as part of a total compensation package, in addition to a full range of medical, financial, and/or other benefits. For more information, visit: https://www.aboutamazon.com/workplace/employee-benefits.#0000
US, VA, Arlington
PXT Central Science is seeking an exceptional Data Scientist to join our team. The ideal candidate will thrive in a dynamic, multifaceted role where you'll translate complex business challenges into rigorous quantitative frameworks, extract actionable insights from structured and unstructured datasets, and architect science-backed, scalable solutions that elevate the experience of our 1 million+ employees worldwide. If you're energized by the opportunity to apply data science to our mission of making Amazon Earth's Best Employer, we want to hear from you. Key job responsibilities • Own the design, development, and maintenance of scalable models and prototypes leveraging statistical, machine learning, or GenAI methodologies to enhance employee experience. • Partner with scientists, engineers, and product leaders to solve for employee experience defects using scientific approaches, building new services and tools that deliverable measurable impact. • Author and maintain detailed technical documentation related to the projects you drive. • Communicate results to diverse audiences of varying technical background with effective writing, visualizations, and presentations • Stay current with emerging methods and technologies, and implement them strategically to amplify the team’s impact. About the team The Central Science Team within Amazon’s People Experience and Technology org (PXTCS) uses economics, behavioral science, statistics, machine learning, and Generative AI to proactively identify mechanisms and process improvements which simultaneously improve Amazon and the lives, well-being, and the value of work to Amazonians. We are an interdisciplinary team, which combines the talents of science, engineering, and UX to develop and deliver solutions that measurably achieve this goal.
US, CA, Pasadena
The Amazon Web Services (AWS) Center for Quantum Computing (CQC) in Pasadena, CA, is hiring an Applied Scientist to lead integration research and development for superconducting quantum devices. You will design, model, and test the chip-to-chip, chip-to-package, and signal-delivery interfaces that let superconducting quantum computers scale, and you will characterize integrated assemblies at cryogenic temperatures to learn how integration choices affect qubit performance, yield, and manufacturability. You will join a multi-disciplinary team of theoretical and experimental physicists, materials scientists, and hardware and software engineers working at the forefront of quantum computing. You will carry integration technologies from concept through hardware demonstration, build the test standards and automation that make results reproducible across devices, and collaborate with fabrication, hardware, and circuit design engineers to remove the dominant sources of yield loss. You will also contribute to multi-year roadmap planning for integration and scaling capabilities and help establish the scientific foundation for this capability area within the Device team. Key job responsibilities In this role you will develop the integration technologies that let superconducting quantum computers scale. Your work will span four connected areas: - Integration research and development: Design, model, and test integration solutions for superconducting quantum devices, including chip-to-chip, chip-to-package, and signal-delivery interfaces. Build electromagnetic, thermal, and mechanical models to predict and optimize performance, and characterize integrated assemblies at cryogenic temperatures. - Scaling technologies: Develop and evaluate approaches to scaling superconducting quantum hardware against yield, reusability, manufacturability, and scalability, and carry the most promising ones from concept through hardware demonstration. - Test standards and automation: Define test standards that give rigorous, reproducible measurements of how integration affects qubit coherence, loss, and crosstalk. Automate data collection and reporting against these standards so characterization scales across devices and configurations. - Yield and manufacturability: Work with fabrication, hardware, printed circuit board, and circuit design engineers to identify and remove the largest sources of yield loss and integration uncertainty, and to design processes and components that are reused across device generations and manufactured at scale. About the team The Device team at the AWS Center for Quantum Computing designs, builds, and measures the superconducting quantum devices at the heart of our processors, and develops the integration and packaging that turn individual devices into working systems. You will work alongside physicists, materials scientists, and hardware and software engineers across design, fabrication, measurement, and theory, in a lab built for rapid iteration from concept to cryogenic test. Over the coming years the team's focus is making superconducting quantum hardware scale, and this role establishes integration as a scientific capability area within that effort. Why AWS? Amazon Web Services (AWS) is the world's most comprehensive and broadly adopted cloud platform. We pioneered cloud computing and never stopped innovating — that's why customers from the most successful startups to Global 500 companies trust our robust suite of products and services to power their businesses. AWS Utility Computing (UC) provides product innovations — from foundational services such as Amazon's Simple Storage Service (S3) and Amazon Elastic Compute Cloud (EC2), to consistently released new product innovations that continue to set AWS's services and features apart in the industry. As a member of the UC organization, you'll support the development and management of Compute, Database, Storage, Internet of Things (IoT), Platform, and Productivity Apps services in AWS. Within AWS UC, Amazon Dedicated Cloud (ADC) roles engage with AWS customers who require specialized security solutions for their cloud services. Inclusive Team Culture: Here at AWS, it's in our nature to learn and be curious. Our employee-led affinity groups foster a culture of inclusion that empower us to be proud of our differences. Ongoing events and learning experiences, including our Conversations on Race and Ethnicity (CORE) and AmazeCon (diversity) conferences, inspire us to never stop embracing our uniqueness. Diverse Experiences: AWS values diverse experiences. Even if you do not meet all of the preferred qualifications and skills listed in the job description, we encourage candidates to apply. If your career is just starting, hasn't followed a traditional path, or includes alternative experiences, don't let it stop you from applying. Mentorship & Career Growth: We're continuously raising our performance bar as we strive to become Earth's Best Employer. That's why you'll find endless knowledge-sharing, mentorship and other career-advancing resources here to help you develop into a better-rounded professional. Work/Life Balance: We value work-life harmony. Achieving success at work should never come at the expense of sacrifices at home, which is why we strive for flexibility as part of our working culture. When we feel supported in the workplace and at home, there's nothing we can't achieve in the cloud.
US, WA, Seattle
MULTIPLE POSITIONS AVAILABLE Employer: AMAZON.COM SERVICES LLC Offered Position: Applied Scientist II Job Location: Seattle, Washington Job Number: AMZ10564086 Position Responsibilities: Participate in the design, development, evaluation, deployment and updating of data-driven models and analytical solutions for machine learning (ML) and/or natural language (NL) applications. Develop and/or apply statistical modeling techniques (e.g. Bayesian models and deep neural networks), optimization methods, and other ML techniques to different applications in business and engineering. Routinely build and deploy ML models on available data. Research and implement novel ML and statistical approaches to add value to the business. Mentor junior engineers and scientists. Specialize in the field of Computational Advertising, directly advancing the techniques in Online Advertising Technology focusing on model optimization and latency reduction. Develop sophisticated machine learning algorithms and models using PyTorch. Develop advanced deep learning architectures to automate the discovery of complex, non-linear feature interactions, effectively capturing high-dimensional data patterns that traditional statistical models are unable to process. Investigate and implement high-order feature interaction architectures, such as DeepFM and DCN-V2, using PyTorch to capture complex non-linear relationships within sparse categorical datasets. Develop custom embedding layers in PyTorch to map high-dimensional, sparse features (e.g., Ad IDs) into dense, low-dimensional vector spaces. Conduct systematic research into the trade-offs between model architecture complexity and inference speed, utilizing PyTorch profiling tools to identify and optimize bottleneck layers. 40 hours / week, 8:00am-5:00pm, Salary Range: $163,617/year to $193,200/year Amazon is a total compensation company. Dependent on the position offered, equity, sign-on payments, and other forms of compensation may be provided as part of a total compensation package, in addition to a full range of medical, financial, and/or other benefits. For more information, visit: https://www.aboutamazon.com/workplace/employee-benefits. Amazon.com is an Equal Opportunity-Affirmative Action Employer – Minority / Female / Disability / Veteran / Gender Identity / Sexual Orientation.#0000
CA, BC, Vancouver
Building AI first solutions in a complex regulated space at Amazon scale. Would you like to work on one of the world's largest product classification and Tax computation engine? Or perhaps teaching AI to understanding nuances of domain specific language is what piques your interest? We are responsible for the tax calculation platform, providing the core services that calculate indirect taxes (sales tax and VAT) for all Amazon sales, physical and digital, globally. We are responsible for classifying billions of products in Amazon’s catalogue, calculating accurate Tax amount for every transaction that happens on Amazon’s global platform. Our engineering services are relied upon globally, built to be resilient across some of highest peak traffic demands in the world, while constantly evolving with the state of the art technology. We use language models at scale for Tax classification of the diverse products in Amazon catalogue and comprehending nuances of legislations and legal parlour.Our challenges include staying on top of the complex and fast-changing global tax legislations while ensuring computing calculations correctly and quickly, thousands of times a second, and each one needs to be accurate. Applied Scientists in Tax Engine works closely with Tax specialists, Product team , SDEs and Business teams - tackling a growing portfolio of core-science problems that includes balance of predictive and generative AI -including language comprehension, causal reasoning and active learning. As an Applied scientist, you will provide machine learning expertise to the team that helps increase the accuracy of Tax classification based on product information in Amazon catalogue. You will build various machine learning models to predict accuracy of tax classification, work with large reasoning models to reason with large volumes of system data and expert artefacts to teach domain intuition to AI. You will on variety of legislative changes acting as causal determinants to changes in our systems. You will help us innovate different ways to enhance for our global customers of Amazon.You will need to be entrepreneurial, work in a highly collaborative environment with SDEs, Product managers and businesses. We like to move fast, experiment, iterate and then scale quickly, thoughtfully balancing speed and quality. Whether you're passionate about taking your scientific solves to global reach and scale or one who seeks to solve complex problems under high scrutiny of an audited field, Tax Engine’s scope could offer you an intersting challenge to solve.